Ranked guide · Key West, Florida
Plastic Surgeons in Key West, ranked (2026)
The honest read on Key West surgery: two tracked providers, 267 total reviews, and Keys Med Spa is the only one that tags cosmetic procedures. Brien W. Tonkinson, MD, holds 241 reviews at 4.8 with no tagged cosmetic procedures, and Keys Med Spa on MacDonald Avenue, 26 reviews at 4.8, lists facelift and labiaplasty as its tracked cosmetic procedures. The best-rated surgeons in the nearest cities are listed below the local practices. For breast and body surgery the practical bench is Miami, a four-hour drive up the Overseas Highway, and many islanders schedule surgery and recovery on the mainland. Verify American Board of Plastic Surgery certification wherever you consult, and weigh follow-up logistics before choosing a mainland surgeon.
How we ranked these: by public Google rating weighted by
review volume (a Bayesian average), as of 2026. This list is editorial and not influenced by payment. Always confirm current credentials, availability, and pricing directly with each practice.
Only 2 plastic surgery practices in Key West meet our listing bar
(a practice's own website names a procedure we list, with a public Google rating of 4.3 or better across 25 or more reviews).
The best-rated surgeons in the nearest cities are listed below it.
Photos from each practice's Google Business Profile.
Nearby 
Plastic surgeons near Key West
The best-rated practices in the closest cities that have a surgeon page, nearest city first. Each card opens the practice's profile in its own city.
Naples, FL · 176 km away
Naples, FL · 176 km away
Naples, FL · 176 km away
Doral, FL · 185 km away
Doral, FL · 185 km away
Doral, FL · 185 km away
Coral Gables, FL · 186 km away
Coral Gables, FL · 186 km away
How to vet a plastic surgeon
Three checks before any consultation deposit: certification by the American Board of Plastic Surgery (in Canada, Royal College certification, FRCSC), surgery performed in an accredited facility, and a direct answer to "how many of my exact procedure do you perform each year?" A reputable surgeon welcomes all three questions. Be cautious with heavy discounting and package deals: surgery is the wrong purchase to optimize on price.