Skip to content
ClinicCompass
Peoria, Illinois

Ranked guide · Peoria, Illinois

The 5 Best Plastic Surgeons in Peoria (2026)

The 1001 Main Street medical building is Peoria's surgical address: Dr. Robin Alley practices from it. Peoria Heights adds Dr. Tyler Evans, whose 134-review practice carries the market's clearest cosmetic menu, rhinoplasty through mommy makeovers, alongside Dr. Michael Romanelli on Prospect Road, and Merheb Surgical Arts on Executive Drive keeps rare Saturday hours. The five listings hold 358 reviews at a 4.76 average. Three of the five tag no cosmetic procedure, so ask each surgeon directly about cosmetic caseload, and verify American Board of Plastic Surgery certification.

How we ranked these: by public Google rating weighted by review volume (a Bayesian average), as of 2026. This list is editorial and not influenced by payment. Always confirm current credentials, availability, and pricing directly with each practice.
  1. 1

    Tyler A. Evans, MD, FACS

    4616 N Prospect Rd, Peoria Heights, IL 61616

    4.9 (147) · Google
    View profile
  2. 2

    Michael R. Romanelli, MD

    4616 N Prospect Rd, Peoria Heights, IL 61616

    5.0 (75) · Google
    View profile
  3. 3

    Robin A. Alley, MD, FACS

    1001 Main St, Peoria, IL 61606

    4.9 (53) · Google
    View profile
  4. 4

    Jeffries James M MD

    4909 N Glen Park Pl, Peoria, IL 61614

    4.6 (30) · Google
    View profile
  5. 5

    Merheb Surgical Arts

    5009 N Executive Dr Ste A, Peoria, IL 61614

    Open Saturdays
    4.3 (102) · Google
    View profile

Photos from each practice's Google Business Profile.

How to vet a plastic surgeon

Three checks before any consultation deposit: certification by the American Board of Plastic Surgery (in Canada, Royal College certification, FRCSC), surgery performed in an accredited facility, and a direct answer to "how many of my exact procedure do you perform each year?" A reputable surgeon welcomes all three questions. Be cautious with heavy discounting and package deals: surgery is the wrong purchase to optimize on price.

All Peoria clinics → Best med spas in Peoria →