Ranked guide · Staten Island, New York
The 10 Best Plastic Surgeons in Staten Island (2026)
Staten Island keeps more surgical coverage than any outer-borough market we have listed: eight of eleven listings perform facelifts and five carry the full rhinoplasty-through-liposuction menu. Dr. Vitolo's 150-review Richmond Road practice runs Saturday hours to 10 PM, nearly unheard of in surgery, Dr. Joseph Costa covers fourteen procedures from South Avenue, and Dr. Louis Cutolo's Victory Boulevard office has served the North Shore for decades. Allure Plastic Surgery and Dr. Elliot Heller bridge the island and their East 61st Street Manhattan offices, so confirm where your procedure would actually happen. The 638-review book at Staten Island Oral and Maxillofacial is jaw surgery, not cosmetic. Ten listings, 4.89 average, 1,301 reviews. Verify American Board of Plastic Surgery certification either side of the bridge.
- 2
- 7
- 8
Photos from each practice's Google Business Profile.
How to vet a plastic surgeon
Three checks before any consultation deposit: certification by the American Board of Plastic Surgery (in Canada, Royal College certification, FRCSC), surgery performed in an accredited facility, and a direct answer to "how many of my exact procedure do you perform each year?" A reputable surgeon welcomes all three questions. Be cautious with heavy discounting and package deals: surgery is the wrong purchase to optimize on price.